Clance Impostor Phenomenon Scale: What It Measures and How It’s Scored

Ever handed in a thesis chapter, received praise from your supervisor, and thought: “If they only knew how little I actually understand this”? That quiet fear of being exposed as a fraud has a name — the impostor phenomenon — and the clance impostor phenomenon scale is the standard tool researchers use to measure it. If you are a PhD student or early-career researcher, this scale has probably appeared in studies you have read. This guide explains what the scale measures, how its 20 items work, how to score it, and how to interpret the result — including how to use it properly in your own thesis.

What Is the Clance Impostor Phenomenon Scale?

The Clance Impostor Phenomenon Scale (CIPS) is a 20-item self-report questionnaire that measures how strongly a person experiences impostor feelings — the persistent sense of being a fraud despite clear evidence of success. It was developed by clinical psychologist Pauline Rose Clance and published in her 1985 book, The Impostor Phenomenon: When Success Makes You Feel Like a Fake.

The idea behind the scale goes back further. In 1978, Clance and Suzanne Imes published the paper that first described the impostor phenomenon, based on their clinical work with high-achieving women who felt they had fooled everyone into thinking they were competent. The women they studied were objectively successful — strong grades, promotions, publications — yet lived with the fear that someone would eventually discover they did not belong. Clance built the scale to turn that clinical observation into something researchers could measure consistently.

Today the CIPS is the most widely used measure of impostor feelings in research. It has been used with students, academics, doctors, engineers, and professionals across many countries, and translated into numerous languages. If your thesis involves impostor syndrome, self-doubt, or academic wellbeing, this is very likely the instrument your supervisor will expect you to consider first.

What Does the CIPS Measure?

The scale measures one overall construct — the intensity of impostor experiences — but the items cluster around three themes that Clance identified from her clinical work. The validation study by Chrisman and colleagues (1995) found that the items grouped into three factors, which researchers usually describe as follows:

  • Fake — feeling like a fraud. The core experience: believing you are less capable than others think, and worrying that people will discover the gap. Items in this theme ask about feeling like an impostor and fearing exposure.
  • Discount — dismissing your own achievements. The habit of explaining away success instead of owning it. Items here cover attributing accomplishments to luck, timing, charm, or other people rather than your own ability.
  • Luck — crediting chance instead of competence. Closely related to discounting, this theme captures the belief that success happened because of being in the right place at the right time, or because of some error or fluke.

These three themes are not separate subscales you should score on their own. The research on the factor structure is mixed — some studies support three factors, others find two or even one — so the standard advice is to use the total score only. Report the single total, and treat the three themes as a helpful way to understand what the items cover, not as three mini-scales.

Items and Response Format

The CIPS has 20 items. Each item is a short statement about an impostor-related thought or feeling, and respondents rate how true each statement is for them on a 5-point scale:

  • 1 — Not at all true
  • 2 — Rarely true
  • 3 — Sometimes true
  • 4 — Often true
  • 5 — Very true

The statements cover familiar impostor experiences: succeeding on a task while fearing beforehand that you would fail; worrying that praise will raise expectations you cannot meet; avoiding evaluations; remembering failures far more vividly than successes; finding it hard to accept compliments; and feeling discouraged if you are not the best at something. To give you the flavour without reproducing the copyrighted items, a typical item asks whether you worry that people important to you will discover you are not as capable as they believe — that fear of being “found out” runs through the whole scale.

One practical point matters a great deal: use the items exactly as published. The scale is copyrighted by Clance, and the official guidance is clear that paraphrasing or rewording items changes what is being measured and makes your results impossible to compare with the published literature. For research use, obtain the official version and the permission guidance from the scale’s official website (clanceimpostorphenomenonscale.org) before you collect data. For classroom discussion or a thesis proposal, describing the themes and the scoring system — as this post does — is enough; you do not need to reproduce all 20 items.

How to Score the CIPS

Scoring the CIPS is refreshingly simple. There are no reverse-scored items — every item is scored in the same direction, from 1 to 5. Just add up the responses to all 20 items. The total score ranges from 20 to 100, and a higher score means more frequent and intense impostor experiences.

Clance proposed four interpretive bands for the total score:

Total scoreInterpretation
40 or belowFew impostor characteristics
41–60Moderate impostor experiences
61–80Frequent impostor feelings
81–100Intense impostor experiences

Two things are worth noting. First, these bands are descriptive guides, not diagnostic cut-offs. The CIPS is a research instrument, not a clinical test — impostor phenomenon is not a diagnosis in the DSM-5-TR or ICD-11, and no score on this scale means someone “has” a disorder. Second, the validation work suggested that a score of 61 or higher is clinically meaningful: in the original validation studies, people scoring in this range were the ones whose impostor experiences were confirmed in detailed clinical interviews.

Worked Example: Scoring a Response Set

Imagine a fictional PhD student, Ayesha, in her second year. She has just passed her confirmation review, yet she is convinced the examiners were being kind. She completes the CIPS honestly. On most items she answers 3 (sometimes true) or 4 (often true): she often fears she will not live up to praise, sometimes credits luck for her results, and often remembers her mistakes more than her successes. On a few items — such as avoiding evaluation — she answers 2. On two items about feeling like a fraud when praised, she answers 5.

Adding up her 20 responses gives a total of 64. That falls in the 61–80 band: frequent impostor feelings. The score does not mean Ayesha is failing — she has just passed a major milestone. It means impostor feelings are a regular, disruptive part of her research life, and that is useful information. For a thesis, a result like this would sit in the descriptive statistics; for Ayesha personally, it is a prompt to talk to a supervisor, a counsellor, or peers — many of whom, she would discover, score in the same range.

Interpreting the Score: What Each Band Means

40 or below — few impostor characteristics. The person occasionally doubts themselves, as most people do, but impostor thoughts are rare and do not interfere with work. This is the range you would expect from someone with a secure sense of their own competence.

41–60 — moderate impostor experiences. The most common range in student samples. Impostor feelings show up regularly — before presentations, after praise, around deadlines — but they are manageable and often fade once the moment passes.

61–80 — frequent impostor feelings. Impostor thoughts are a regular feature of daily academic life. The person may over-prepare, avoid applying for opportunities, or discount achievements consistently. This is the range where the validation studies found the experiences confirmed in clinical interviews, so researchers often treat 61 as the threshold for “meaningful” impostor phenomenon.

81–100 — intense impostor experiences. Impostor feelings dominate: constant fear of exposure, chronic self-doubt, and difficulty accepting any evidence of competence. Someone scoring here may benefit from professional support, and a researcher reporting such scores should handle them sensitively and signpost support services.

Always interpret scores at the group level when you report research. A mean score of 58 in a sample of PhD students tells a story about the cohort; a single student’s score of 58 is just one data point, not a verdict on that person.

Reliability and Validity Evidence

A scale is only useful if it measures consistently and measures what it claims to. The evidence for the CIPS is strong, which is a large part of why it has become the default measure:

  • Internal consistency: The validation study by Chrisman and colleagues (1995) reported a Cronbach’s alpha of .92 — well above the usual .70 threshold for research use. Later studies in student and professional samples routinely report alphas in the .90s, and a Spanish validation reported similarly high reliability.
  • Construct validity: The same 1995 validation study showed the CIPS relates to, but is clearly distinguishable from, related constructs such as depression, anxiety, self-esteem, and fear of negative evaluation. Impostor feelings overlap with low self-esteem, for example, but they are not the same thing — and the scale can tell them apart.
  • Factor structure: The original validation supported three factors (Fake, Discount, Luck). Later research has been less unanimous, with some studies finding two factors or one, so most researchers report only the total score. If your thesis committee asks about this, acknowledging the debate is better than pretending it does not exist.
  • Wide use and translation: A systematic review of impostor measures (Mak and colleagues, 2019) found the CIPS to be the most frequently used instrument in the field, and it has been translated and validated in many languages, including German and Spanish versions with good psychometric properties.
  • Prevalence context: A large systematic review (Bravata and colleagues, 2020) covering 62 studies and more than 14,000 participants found reported prevalence of impostor feelings ranging widely — from 9% to 82% depending on the sample and the cut-off used. The wide range is itself a finding: how common impostor feelings look depends heavily on whom you ask and where you draw the line.

CIPS vs Other Impostor Measures

The CIPS is not the only way to measure impostor feelings. Here is how it compares with the main alternatives:

MeasureItemsBest for
Clance Impostor Phenomenon Scale (CIPS)20General research; the most cited and most translated option
Harvey Impostor Phenomenon Scale (HIPS)14Historical interest; largely replaced by the CIPS
Perceived Fraudulence Scale (PFS)51Detailed clinical assessment; long for survey research
Leary Impostorism Scale7Very short surveys where space is tight

For most theses, the CIPS is the right choice: short enough to include in a survey battery, well validated, and instantly recognisable to examiners. The 7-item Leary scale is worth knowing about if questionnaire length is a serious constraint, but you would need to justify choosing a less-established measure.

How to Use the CIPS in Your Research

If you plan to use the scale in a thesis or study, follow these steps:

  1. Get the official version and permission. The scale is copyrighted. Visit the official CIPS website for the authorised items and guidance on research use. Do not copy items from a random blog post — versions circulating online sometimes contain errors or altered wording.
  2. Check whether you need a translation. If your participants do not read English fluently, use a published validated translation for their language where one exists, and report which version you used. Translating the items yourself without validation weakens your study.
  3. Administer it as part of a battery, not alone. The CIPS works best alongside measures of the constructs you want to relate it to — self-esteem, anxiety, perfectionism, or academic self-efficacy, for example.
  4. Report your own reliability. Always calculate and report Cronbach’s alpha for the CIPS in your own sample. Never just quote the .92 from Chrisman et al. (1995) as if it were your result.
  5. Report the full distribution. Give the mean, standard deviation, range, and the percentage of participants in each of the four bands. A mean alone hides the shape of your data.
  6. Handle high scorers ethically. If your study identifies participants with very high scores, your ethics application should say what support you will signpost. A debrief sheet with university counselling contacts is the minimum.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

  • Treating the score as a diagnosis. The CIPS measures experiences, not a disorder. Never write that a participant “has impostor syndrome” based on their score.
  • Scoring the subscales separately. The three factors are a useful description, not three validated subscales. Report the total score.
  • Rewording the items. Changing wording to “fit your context” breaks comparability with every published study. If an item feels awkward for your population, note it as a limitation instead.
  • Using a single cut-off as a diagnosis. Some papers use 62 as a cut-off and others use the median; the bands are guides. Be transparent about whichever approach you choose and why.
  • Forgetting the sample matters. A score of 65 means something different in a sample of first-year undergraduates than in a sample of senior professors. Always describe your participants when you interpret scores.

Frequently Asked Questions

How many items are in the Clance Impostor Phenomenon Scale?

20 items, each rated on a 5-point scale from 1 (not at all true) to 5 (very true). The total score ranges from 20 to 100.

What is a high score on the CIPS?

Scores of 61–80 indicate frequent impostor feelings, and 81–100 indicate intense impostor experiences. Validation research suggests 61 and above is the point where impostor experiences become clinically meaningful.

Are any CIPS items reverse-scored?

No. All 20 items are scored in the same direction, so scoring is a simple sum of the item responses. There is nothing to reverse before adding up the total.

Is the CIPS free to use?

The scale is copyrighted by Pauline Rose Clance. The official website provides the authorised version and guidance for research use — check the permission requirements there before collecting data, rather than copying items from unofficial sources.

Can I use the CIPS to diagnose impostor syndrome?

No. Impostor phenomenon is not a clinical diagnosis, and the CIPS is a research instrument. It describes how often someone experiences impostor feelings; it does not diagnose anything. If you or a participant is struggling, a qualified mental health professional is the right next step.

How to Cite the Clance Impostor Phenomenon Scale

Use APA 7th edition. Cite the original scale and the validation study:

Clance, P. R. (1985). The impostor phenomenon: When success makes you feel like a fake. Peachtree Publishers.

Chrisman, S. M., Pieper, W. A., Clance, P. R., Holland, C. L., & Glickauf-Hughes, C. (1995). Validation of the Clance Impostor Phenomenon Scale. Journal of Personality Assessment, 65(3), 456–467. https://doi.org/10.1207/s15327752jpa6503_6

For the concept itself, cite the original paper:

Clance, P. R., & Imes, S. A. (1978). The impostor phenomenon in high achieving women: Dynamics and therapeutic intervention. Psychotherapy: Theory, Research & Practice, 15(3), 241–247.

Key Takeaways

  • The CIPS is a 20-item, 5-point scale developed by Pauline Rose Clance (1985) and validated by Chrisman et al. (1995). It is the most widely used measure of impostor feelings.
  • Scoring is a simple sum from 20 to 100, with no reverse-scored items: 40 or below means few impostor characteristics, 41–60 moderate, 61–80 frequent, and 81–100 intense.
  • Report the total score only, calculate reliability in your own sample, and never treat the result as a diagnosis.
  • Use the official, authorised version of the items, and cite Clance (1985) and Chrisman et al. (1995) in your thesis.

If impostor feelings are a regular part of your PhD life, you are in large and accomplished company — and now you know exactly how researchers measure them.

Leave a Comment