APA vs MLA vs Chicago is the question almost every student asks at some point — usually the night before a paper is due. The three styles look similar from a distance: they all tell you how to credit sources, format a paper, and build a reference list. But they were built for different disciplines, and they disagree on the details examiners notice first: where the date goes, whether you use footnotes, and what your reference list is even called. This guide compares all three side by side, with real examples and a simple way to choose.
The Short Answer: APA vs MLA vs Chicago at a Glance
If you only have thirty seconds, this table is the whole story.
| APA (7th edition) | MLA (9th edition) | Chicago (17th edition) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Used mainly by | Psychology, education, social sciences, business, nursing | Literature, languages, cultural studies, humanities | History, art history, religion, some social sciences |
| In-text citation | Author and year: (Smith, 2020) | Author and page: (Smith 23) | Footnote or author and year: (Smith 2020, 23) |
| Reference list called | References | Works Cited | Bibliography (or Reference List) |
| Dates | Front and centre — always in the citation | At the end of the entry — often less prominent | In the note or citation, depending on the system |
| Page numbers in citations | Only for direct quotes | Always, when available | In footnotes, and for quotes in author-date |
| Title page | Required (student and professional versions differ) | No separate title page — name and details on page one | Title page common, especially in Notes and Bibliography |
APA Style (7th Edition): The Social Science Standard
APA is published by the American Psychological Association, and its 7th edition is the current version. If you study psychology, education, sociology, business, or nursing, APA is almost certainly your default style.
How APA cites in the text
APA uses the author-date system. Every in-text citation carries the author’s surname and the year of publication, and a page number is added only when you quote directly.
- Parenthetical citation: Working memory capacity predicts reading comprehension (Daneman & Carpenter, 1980).
- Narrative citation: Daneman and Carpenter (1980) showed that working memory capacity predicts reading comprehension.
- Direct quote: “Reading span predicted comprehension scores” (Daneman & Carpenter, 1980, p. 456).
For a source with three or more authors, APA 7th uses “et al.” from the very first citation: (Smith et al., 2021). Earlier editions waited until the second citation, so if your supervisor learned APA years ago, this is a change worth knowing.
How APA builds the reference list
The list is titled “References”, ordered alphabetically by the first author’s surname, and uses a hanging indent (the first line flush left, the rest indented). Book and article titles use sentence case — only the first word and proper nouns are capitalised — while journal titles use title case and italics. A DOI, when one exists, is given as a full link.
Daneman, M., & Carpenter, P. A. (1980). Individual differences in working memory and reading. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior, 19(4), 450–466. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0022-5371(80)90312-6
APA formatting basics
APA papers are double-spaced throughout, use a readable font such as 11-point Calibri or 12-point Times New Roman, and carry the page number in the top right corner of every page. The student title page carries the title, your name, institution, course, instructor, and due date — no running head; the professional version adds one. Headings follow five levels, with Level 1 centred and bold and Level 2 flush left and bold. For the full detail, see our guides to the APA 7th title page and APA headings.
MLA Style (9th Edition): The Humanities Standard
MLA is published by the Modern Language Association, and its 9th edition is the current version. If you study English literature, foreign languages, philosophy, or cultural studies, MLA is the style your department most likely expects.
How MLA cites in the text
MLA uses the author-page system. There is no year in the citation — the page number does the work, because the argument depends on the exact passage, not on how recent the source is.
- Parenthetical citation: Close reading reveals the narrator’s unreliability from the opening chapter (Booth 158).
- Narrative citation: Booth argues that the narrator’s unreliability is visible from the opening chapter (158).
- Online source without page numbers: Cite the author’s name alone (Booth).
Note that there is no comma between the author and the page number, and no “p.” before it. For three or more authors, MLA also uses “et al.” — (Smith et al. 45).
How MLA builds the Works Cited list
The list is titled “Works Cited”, ordered alphabetically, and also uses a hanging indent. MLA’s signature idea is the “container”: a source sits inside a larger container, and you record both. An article sits inside a journal; a chapter sits inside a book; a video sits inside a website. Source titles use title case, and container titles are italicised.
Booth, Wayne C. The Rhetoric of Fiction. 2nd ed., U of Chicago P, 1983.
Notice the differences from APA: the author’s full first name appears (not just an initial), the year sits near the end of the entry, and the heading reads “Works Cited”, not “References”. Include the DOI whenever a source has one.
MLA formatting basics
MLA papers do not usually have a separate title page. Your name, instructor, course, and date go in the top left corner of the first page, followed by a centred title. The whole paper is double-spaced, the header carries your surname and the page number, and the font is usually 12-point Times New Roman.
Chicago Style (17th Edition): The Historian’s Standard
Chicago is published by the University of Chicago Press, and its 17th edition is the current version. It is the style of history, art history, theology, and much of the humanities — and it is the only one of the three that gives you two complete systems to choose from.
Chicago’s two systems
Notes and Bibliography is the system most people mean when they say “Chicago style”. Sources are cited in footnotes or endnotes, and a bibliography at the end lists every source. It suits subjects where the source deserves space on the page.
A first footnote gives full details: Wayne C. Booth, The Rhetoric of Fiction, 2nd ed. (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1983), 158. Later references to the same source are shortened: Booth, Rhetoric of Fiction, 158. The 17th edition discourages “ibid.” in favour of shortened citations.
Author-Date is Chicago’s second system, used mainly in the sciences and social sciences. It looks familiar if you know APA: (Booth 1983, 158). The reference list is titled “Reference List” rather than “Bibliography”, and its entries closely resemble APA entries, with small differences in punctuation and capitalisation.
How Chicago builds the bibliography
Bibliography entries invert the first author’s name, like MLA, but place the year near the end, and use headline-style capitalisation for book and article titles:
Booth, Wayne C. The Rhetoric of Fiction. 2nd ed. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1983.
Chicago formatting basics
Chicago papers are usually double-spaced with 1-inch margins and 12-point Times New Roman. Notes and Bibliography papers often include a title page, and footnotes are single-spaced with a blank line between notes. Because Chicago offers two systems, always confirm which one your department wants before you start — mixing footnotes with an author-date list is the most common Chicago mistake.
How to Choose: A Simple Decision Guide
Choosing a citation style is rarely a matter of taste. Work through these steps in order, and the decision usually makes itself.
- Check your assignment or journal first. Most assignments name the style outright. A journal’s author guidelines do the same. If a style is specified, use it — that is the whole decision.
- Follow your discipline. Psychology, education, and the social sciences use APA. Literature, languages, and cultural studies use MLA. History and art history use Chicago (Notes and Bibliography). If your department has a style guide, it outranks any general rule.
- Match the style to your evidence. If your argument depends on how recent findings are, APA’s author-date system keeps the year visible. If it depends on exact passages, MLA’s author-page system points straight at them. If your sources need commentary — archives, manuscripts, older editions — Chicago’s footnotes give you room to explain.
- Ask when in doubt. A quick email to your supervisor costs far less than reformatting forty references the night before submission.
One warning: never mix styles in a single paper. A reference list that starts in APA and drifts into MLA tells an examiner the writer was copying formatting from different sources.
Common Mistakes When Switching Between Styles
- Putting the year in an MLA citation. MLA citations have no year — (Smith 23), not (Smith, 2020, p. 23).
- Leaving page numbers out of an MLA citation. APA only needs page numbers for quotes, but MLA needs them whenever the source has pages.
- Using “ibid.” in Chicago. The 17th edition prefers shortened citations (Booth, Rhetoric of Fiction, 158) over ibid.
- Capitalising article titles in APA. APA uses sentence case for article and book titles in the reference list; only the journal name takes title case.
- Forgetting the hanging indent. All three styles use it in the reference list — first line flush left, the rest indented half an inch.
- Trusting a citation generator blindly. Generators are useful, but they regularly produce errors in capitalisation, italics, and DOIs. Always check the output against the style manual for your first few references.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use a different citation style from my classmates?
Only if your assignment allows it. Citation style is usually set by the course, department, or journal — not by personal preference. If no style is specified, choose the one standard in your discipline and use it consistently.
Which style is easiest to learn?
Most students find MLA the quickest to pick up, because its in-text citation is just a name and a page number. APA is the most rule-heavy for formatting, and Chicago’s footnotes take the most time — but “easiest” is the wrong reason to choose. Use the style your field expects.
Do I need a reference list if I use Chicago footnotes?
Usually yes. In Notes and Bibliography, the bibliography lists every source cited, while footnotes carry the detail for each individual citation. Some short papers may use notes alone, but a bibliography is the safer default — check your assignment brief.
What if a source has no author?
All three styles have a rule for this. APA and Chicago (Author-Date) use a shortened version of the title in the in-text citation, and the reference entry begins with the title. MLA uses the title in the in-text citation too, shortening a long title to its first few words.
Is the 7th edition of APA the current one?
Yes. APA 7th edition was published in October 2019 and remains current. MLA 9th edition (2021) and Chicago 17th edition (2017) are likewise the current editions of their styles. If a guide or generator cites an older edition, treat its advice with caution.
The Bottom Line
APA, MLA, and Chicago are not rivals — they are tools built for different kinds of scholarship. APA foregrounds the year because science moves fast. MLA foregrounds the page because literary argument lives in passages. Chicago foregrounds the note because history needs room to discuss its sources. Find out which style your discipline uses, learn its in-text citation pattern and its reference list rules, and apply it consistently from the first draft. Getting the style right will not save a weak argument — but getting it wrong is the easiest way to make a strong one look careless.
Key takeaway: if your assignment names a style, use it. If it doesn’t, use the style of your discipline — APA for the social sciences, MLA for literature and languages, Chicago for history — and use it the same way from the first citation to the last.